top of page

Nobody Tells You They’re Leaving: Why Retention in Circular Marketplaces Starts With Activation

1 hour ago
4 min read

Most retention playbooks assume you can see a customer leave. Subscriptions get cancelled, contracts run out, and churn shows up as a clear event you can measure, predict and try to prevent. For a growing number of apps, none of that applies. Marketplaces, resale platforms and other non-subscription businesses have no exit event to catch. Users don’t leave; they just stop.


At Appsforum London, Lauren Maxwell-Scott, Head of Product Marketing at Depop, explained why that changes how retention works, and why the most valuable retention work at Depop barely looks like retention at all.



Woman speaking at a microphone, gesturing with a clicker at appsforum event.

The churn you can’t see


Lauren learned retention in telco, at O2 and Three. There, churn was easy to see even if it was hard to fix. Customers had to call to leave, explain where they were going and often say why. That visibility supported a huge machine of lifecycle triggers, renewal-timed messages and call-centre retention teams. “There was a trigger, there was a moment and there was a conversation,” she said.


A marketplace offers none of that. “Nobody cancels Depop, nobody deletes it, or we can’t see when they’ve deleted it,” Lauren explained. A user who bought three items last spring and nothing since might be between wardrobe clear-outs, waiting for a new season, between jobs, or gone for good to another app.


In the data, those users look the same. Academic research described this problem as far back as 1987. The theory exists. What’s missing, Lauren argued, is tooling built for it. Most dashboards, models and even job titles in retention marketing assume a contractual relationship.


Where LTV falls short


The default answer is to optimise for lifetime value. Depop does track LTV, but Lauren

Woman speaks at a podium during a conference, holding a clicker, with sponsor logos on a white backdrop behind her.

pointed out a mismatch. LTV assumes a lifetime with a beginning, a middle, some decay and an end you can put a number on. “And I’ve just spent five minutes telling you that we can’t see an end,” she said.


The bigger issue is Depop’s structure. Most marketplaces split into separate supply and demand populations: estate agents and house hunters, drivers and riders, restaurants and diners. Each side is managed separately. Depop is circular. Sellers are often buyers first, and buyers become sellers. “The overlap between the two isn’t an edge case,” Lauren said. “That’s kind of the whole point of the marketplace.”


The result is a self-reinforcing loop. A clear-out produces cash, cash funds a purchase, the wardrobe fills up, and the next clear-out starts the cycle again. “Selling pays for buying,” she said. “Buying is what creates next year’s supply.” Without sellers, buyers have nothing to buy. Without buyers, sellers stop listing. So the metric that matters is less about lifetime value and more about whether the loop is turning.



Woman speaking at a podium at Appsforum, with sponsor logos on a white conference backdrop.

Activation is the real retention lever


This leads to what Lauren called “probably the least glamorous conclusion” she could offer: “A loop that never starts turning is worth nothing.” Lifecycle messaging and win-back campaigns can’t keep alive a user who never bought or listed anything. Depop’s highest-value retention work is really activation.


There are two ways into the loop, and they need different approaches.


Sellers need to list fast and make a first sale fast, because the buzz of a sale drives repeat listing. Depop’s product marketing focuses on removing every reason someone leaves a bag of clothes by the front door unlisted:


  • AI-generated item descriptions from a single photo

  • One-click photo editing in the app

  • Removing selling fees in the US and Australia

  • Education through YouTube, UGC and paid ads for first-time resellers


“None of these look like retention features,” Lauren said, “but every single one of them shortens the time to somebody’s first sale.”


Buyers take longer. They need the right inventory at the right price, a smooth buying experience, and features that give them a reason to open the app beyond making a purchase.


Outfits lets users build and share looks from listings, a Pinterest-style space to browse without buying. An algorithmic feed improves the more it’s used. Trends draws on what buyers are searching for and feeds it back to sellers as a prompt for what to list. This links the two sides of the loop inside one feature.


The moment Depop cares about most is when a user goes from one reason to visit to two: when a buyer becomes a seller, or a seller starts spending.


Making “sell to buy” a habit

Woman in white shirt speaks at a podium with microphone, holding a clicker, in front of sponsor logos on a conference stage.

Lauren described “sell to buy” as Depop’s strongest retention technique. The more a user sees their clear-out as funding their next purchase, the more engaged they become on both sides.


Depop pushes this idea through above-the-line, through-the-line and educational comms, including its “Depopanomics” campaign. The campaign frames resale as a swap: sell a puffer jacket to buy a denim jacket, swap retail for resale. It works as an acquisition ad, but it is “also doing a massive retention job,” she said.


The product mechanism behind it is Depop Balance, a digital wallet where sale proceeds land. Users can withdraw their money, but with typical casual transactions of $10–30, many leave it in their balance and spend it on the platform. Lauren called it “an extremely powerful re-engagement tool.” A balance reminder does two jobs at once: it gives users something to spend, and it reminds them they’ve made money and could list again.


Re-engagement isn’t a separate discipline


Lauren argued that for a circular marketplace, re-engagement doesn’t need its own playbook. Without a subscription to discount or a contract end date to work towards, “we really only have the products that we have in order to bring people back into the app.”


So every product feature does both jobs. Depop’s go-to-market planning targets existing users and also considers how each launch can bring lapsed users back. Outfits, for example, is a feature few others in resale offer, and it gives a returning user an easy, low-pressure reason to look around.


The wider takeaway for non-subscription apps is that the line between activation, retention and re-engagement may not exist the way traditional models assume. “For a circular marketplace like ours, the normal retention or LTV models just don’t really fit us,” Lauren said. “For us, it’s the same work as getting somebody started in the first place.”

Comments


bottom of page